Noita

It's rare to see a game with a truly unique concept. I suppose it's usually that innovation is difficult - it's much easier to make something you've already seen. But also that there is risk in innovation - if no one's done it before, there's no telling how fun it might be. I can't say Noita is completely unique, because it heavily reminds me of the various powder toys I liked to play around with a decade or so ago, except Noita has many more elements, many more interactions, an immensely larger world, and the whole thing is gamified into an action roguelike.

I find it an absoute technical feat, creating such a large world where every little block, basically every pixel, is simulated in realtime. I think Noita deserves recognition for this alone. They've further managed to add an exploration element into the game, tasking you with learning how things react, what are the effects of various substances on you and your enemies, and figuring out good combinations of spells and tactics.
I was very excited for the first few hours, being a small floaty wizard in a large cave filled with unknown things. Sure, I died often, but each new run I started off with slightly different spells, found new wands, new things, and the game was constantly fresh. I set fire to things, zapped water and metal with electricity, and a particular highlight was conjuring up enough water to create a shield that slowed incoming projectiles to a standstill before they could hit me. There was a lot to see and a lot to do, but my experiences were somewhat disjointed...

On one hand there was this amazing physics simulator that was asking to be explored. On the other, there were these shooty bad guys trying to get you to die and not explore the former. A particular place of conflict was the permadeath nature of the game combined with it taking a while before you could get to the really fun stuff. I felt my exploration stifled by the nagging "don't do anything too crazy, lest we take these fun tools away from you" feeling. Indeed, after the starting options became familiar, most of my game time was spent just shooting at enemies and flying, maybe sometimes digging, through the levels. I found an interesting interaction every now and then, but they rarely performed better than just "shoot more inert bullets at them".

So, yeah, a shame. I don't even know what they could do to improve these problems. Just removing the physics part would leave us a not-too-unique shooter, which I find to be the main gameplay of this game already. Removing the shooting bits would leave us with not a game, but just a larger version of the powder toys of old. While Noita is a technical feat, the two main components that make it up fail to be used harmoniously together. Apart, they just fail to keep my attention for too long.
But hey, even if I can't personally recommend it, the 95% positive reviews on Steam are not to be laughed at. If what I described feels a bit like what you'd want to experience, you don't have to take my word for the game not being so fun.