Gloomhaven

I've always been at least moderately suspicious of video games that have been made from board games. Not that I have anything against board games, far from it, but a board game has a set of limitations on it (simple enough rules to be memorized and applied by humans, limited board sizes, no information hidden from all players, etc.) that a video game does not. So I usually leave board games to be played in person, and stick to video games while online. I was, however, willing to make an exception for Gloomhaven, not just because it's the highest rated board game, but because I was asked to. So, having played it, I might as well review it, but keep my overall stance on board games in mind, if you wish.

Gloomhaven is a tactical, deck-based RPG. You choose a class, assemble a party of up to 4 characeters / players, and set off to a scenario, possibly as part of a longer campaign during which you can upgrade your character with new cards, new equipment, and even a slightly more beneficial RNG. Each scenario has you accomplishing some goal, usually killing all enemies. Unlike most RPGs, Gloomhaven places much greater stakes on each action. You are limited by your deck size, and will lose if you run out of cards, placing you on a turn limit. Additionally, you may choose to burn some cards instead of recycling them in order to get a more powerful effect - bringing forward the time of your inevitable demise, but potentially making up for it by clearing enemies or preventing them doing a lot of damage to you.
Enemies usually hit for a lot, and you're expected to know how the AI works and abuse that knowledge to the fullest by manipulating your turn order, unit placement, and whatever else you can to exploit the specifically-dumb AI. This works well in a board game, but I find it makes the game unnecessarily slow online. This is an addition to the already commonly slow pace of board games that stems from generally being played one turn at a time, one player at a time. Further, there is a widespread problem with turn-based PvE games in general, where it's usually more efficient for one person to call the shots and coordinate everything, than everyone making their own decisions. This of course means that unless everyone is on an equal skill level, either the better players have to bottle up their knowledge and stay silent, watching less experienced players make mistakes and bring the party down. Or the less experienced players don't get much autonomy, and thus not much fun out of the game. This is not something inherent to Gloomhaven, but Gloomhaven also isn't exempt from this.

I think that's most of it. Not much specific about Gloomhaven. In fact, I quite like the idea that you're more solving open-ended puzzles than playing an RPG, and I bet Gloomhaven would be quite nice to play in person. But mainly due to the high amount of time spent waiting, I just can't give the game a recommendation over something designed for a computer first and foremost.